Featuring analysis from

  • IHS
  • DisplaySearch
  • &
  • Solarbuzz

Apple TV… Google TV… Smart TV… What About My TV?

By Paul Gagnon – Director, North American TV Research, DisplaySearch

Apple announced an update to its Apple TV product, which has been referred to as one of Steve Jobs’s hobbies. It will now be 1/4 the size of the previous generation, and 1/3 the price at $99. With no local storage, everything is streamed to the device via wired Ethernet or built-in 802.11n Wi-Fi. It has the requisite HDMI output along with optical audio and USB, and since the power supply is integrated, there’s no power brick either.

In the past, Apple TV was a pretty slick device that allowed users to seamlessly connect their TVs to iTunes content. And that was the fatal flaw that kept Apple TV from becoming a success: limited access to new content. iTunes has always had new movies, TV shows and music available for purchase, but the variety of content and the lack of true streaming meant significant limitations placed on Apple TV’s utility.

So will I buy a new Apple TV for $99? Yes. Probably two of them: one for the living room and one for the bedroom. Here’s why.

I like the interface a lot and buy all of my music through iTunes, but not my TV shows or movies. In fact, I prefer to rent my movies and DVR my TV shows since I refuse to pay for something I can watch for free on broadcast TV. In the past Apple has charged $2 or more to buy these TV shows, which was far too much. But I hate paying nearly $100 a month to my pay-TV provider to watch a few dozen shows on a handful of channels. I’d much rather just pay for access to the channels I watch frequently or just the shows, but at the $0.99 per show Jobs just announced, it’s still too pricey, especially for content from the major networks. But the battle for the living room between traditional media/CE companies and new age internet/IT companies is just heating up.

I have been looking for the utopia of a single, discreet device that aggregates all of my content from every device in the house so that I can watch it on my HDTV, the best screen in the home. All previous devices I have tried in the past, from HP’s Entertainment Notebook PC to Sony’s latest Blu-ray player with BRAVIA internet video, have been disappointing in some way, usually in ease of use, set-up and seamless integration. The biggest problem has been accessing my personal content. The full-fledged PC approach resulted in poor performance and limited ability to navigate content easily. The networked Blu-ray player from Sony worked brilliantly for Netflix and their other content partners, but the DLNA access to my home server and PCs has been a problem. DLNA was a nightmare to set up and use in the best of circumstances, and completely unusable in the worst.

The key for me is that it has to work right away, with limited and easy set up, and provide access to the content I use most frequently. I am technology-savvy, but I have little patience for CE devices that are hard to use. With the new iOS 4.2 coming in November for the iPhone (we own two) and iPad (which I do not own, yet) and the built-in AirPlay feature, the Apple TV will be able to wirelessly stream movies, photos and videos from the iPhones, along with the same content from my PC.

I greatly appreciate the seamless way Apple integrates their devices and services; while they cost a little more, my experience has shown me that there is value to this. I buy all of my music through iTunes, and stream movies from Netflix (which the Apple TV will support), but have lacked the ability to easily watch my own photos and videos, let alone stream music to the living room. Apple TV seems like it will do all of this, and use an excellent, beautiful user interface I am familiar with. I may even start buying some movies from iTunes if the release window is better than Netflix currently is for streaming. And I’ve still got a Blu-ray player for the absolute latest movie releases on DVD.

Now if I can just find a way to cut the cable altogether and not miss out on time-shifted free broadcast shows and cable network shows. Will Google TV devices from Logitech and Sony be competitive in both price and performance? Few details have emerged. Can a coalition of companies be as seamless and effective as a single company? I hope the content partnerships start getting sorted out soon and that the cable and satellite companies find a way to work harmoniously in the coming digital TV revolution. The alternative is ugly; just look at the pain the music industry has endured for the past decade.

  • http://www.multimedia-software-apple.blogspot.com/ stonee

    I’ll choose Google TV, because apple has so many compititors, SAMSUNG, blackberry… (iphone 4, ipad). It’s an astonishing phenomena that apple provide users the same content (services) as its compititors with itunes, And the video converter and dvd ripper are no bussiness of “apple” or “blackberry”(both can use them)…on free offline videos (you can get many free videos converter and dvd rippers which are working on windows and different with handbrake from aneesoft official website, but ifunia is should be paid for apple devices on mac). So I’ll choose which can offer many of the entertainment sources online.

  • Michael T.

    Try using Vuse if you want to stream vids/pics to a DLNA compatible TV. Rather easy and no setup required.

  • david w.

    If you want to “cut the cable altogether” then try free over-the-air. The quality is better and you can Tivo it just like the cable. What we really need is true á la carte programming from cable and satellite. People are tired of paying for programming that they don’t watch.

  • zisel

    Hi, “stonee”
    I agree with you.
    What made me most excited is the Apple TV. only $0.99 to stream HD TV rentals from ABC and Fox, while first run HD movies will be a less thrilling $4.99. Other services include Netflix, YouTube, Flickr, and Mobile Me, along with Rotten Tomatoes integration in the movie catalog. Awesome, so cool and amazing!
    That means I don’t need to buy other converting tools anymore?

    By the way, I love all kinds of movies and videos, and I’m a mac user,so I use iFunia vidoe converter most frequently, thanks to this App helps me convert and save all kinds of movies and videos on my iphone, ipad.

  • http://www.displaysearchblog.com/2011/10/the-in-home-tv-ecosystem-stinks/ The In-Home TV Ecosystem Stinks | DisplaySearch Blog

    [...] a strong link to the TV. I have a pair of Apple TV 2s, each connected to a flat panel TV that I had hoped to use to greater effect to bring content from my mobile devices (computers, phones, etc.) to the biggest screen in the [...]

  • http://www.displaysearchblog.com/2010/11/a-tale-of-two-boxes/ A Tale of Two Boxes | DisplaySearch Blog

    [...] and I had no simple way to play my videos and photos in the living room. So I was easy prey to the AppleTV value proposition, especially at a price of [...]